We are excited to highlight the latest work by Assistant Professor Alejandra Márquez Guajardo in The Conversation. Her recently published article, “Emilia Pérez was nominated for 13 Oscars – why do so many people hate it?,” offers an insightful critique of the film’s reception and the broader implications of LGBTQ+ representation in media.
Examining the Emilia Pérez Controversy
In her latest article, Dr. Márquez Guajardo explores why Emilia Pérez, despite earning 13 Oscar nominations, has faced substantial criticism. As a scholar focused on gender and sexuality studies in Latin America, she analyzes the film’s portrayal of Mexico and trans women, questioning why a work praised for its groundbreaking themes has not been universally embraced.
“As a scholar of gender and sexuality in Latin America, I study LGBTQ+ representation in media, particularly in Mexico. So it’s been interesting to follow the negative reaction to a film that critics claim has broken new ground in exploring themes of gender, sexuality and violence in Mexico.” – Dr. Márquez Guajardo
A key focus of Dr. Márquez Guajardo’s analysis is the film’s struggle to present an intersectional depiction of culture. She highlights how gender, language, and social status shape narratives about marginalized communities. While Emilia Pérez seeks to elevate trans representation, its portrayal has sparked debate over its authenticity and depth.
Dr. Márquez Guajardo argues that Oscar nominations do not necessarily equate to universal acceptance. The film industry often dictates narratives around gender identity and cultural authenticity, which may not always align with the lived experiences of those being represented. Her article invites deeper discussion on the responsibilities of filmmakers in portraying marginalized identities accurately and sensitively.
Professor Márquez Guajardo’s work continues to push boundaries in Latin American studies, gender theory, and cultural criticism. To learn more, you can read her full article on The Conversation here.
About Professor Alejandra Márquez Guajardo
Professor Alejandra Márquez Guajardo is an Assistant Professor of Spanish in MSU’s Department of Romance and Classical Studies. She holds a Ph.D. in Romance Languages and Literatures from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (2018) and an M.A. in Spanish from Texas A&M International University. Her research spans contemporary Latin American literature, queer/cuir studies in Latin America, contemporary Mexican chronicle, gendered narratives of northern Mexico, gender identity and transgressions, depictions of state-sponsored violence, and Latinx literature and culture.
